Macdill Afb Flight Schedule, Articles T
">
275 Walton Street, Englewood, NJ 07631

the cay timothy are you still black

Phillip and Timothy arrive on a small cay. And I'll tell you why. Phillip and Timothy talk about their cay a lot. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Yes. After clearing the debris, he digs with his hands. Phillip has been raised with a prejudicial attitude towards Black people and is suspicious of the man. They took Phillip off the island and he went back home where at the. Take this two-piece set of wall photographic art for example it features black and white images of the water canals in Venice, Italy. The two characters have been on the island for 48 days, and Phillip is becoming quite independent. Psychological Research & Experimental Design, All Teacher Certification Test Prep Courses, Holt McDougal Literature Grade 9 Common Core Edition: Online Textbook Help, Common Core ELA - Informational Text Grades 9-10: Standards, CLEP Analyzing & Interpreting Literature: Study Guide & Test Prep, Technical Writing Syllabus Resource & Lesson Plans, AP English Literature Syllabus Resource & Lesson Plans, Study.com SAT Writing & Language Test Section: Review & Practice, AP English Language Syllabus Resource & Lesson Plans, NMTA Essential Academic Skills Subtest Writing (002): Practice & Study Guide, Working Scholars Bringing Tuition-Free College to the Community. Phillip and Timothy arrive on a small cay. Why did Timothy teach Phillip how to fish? The Cay is a historical fiction adventure novel written by author Theodore Taylor and published in 1969. He's never had anything to do with them. Trouble arises when Timothy becomes suspicious of Stew Cat as being bad luck. As a boy, he formed a dream of one day being captain of his own schooner, which he meant to name after the woman he called "Tante Hannah." It is only after several hours that Phillip asks the man his name. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. When he asked Timothy, "Are you still black?" he is stating how surprised he is by how close they have become. b) Phillip finds a dozen fishing poles with barbed hooks and bolt sinkers that Timothy has lashed to a tree for him. Theodore Taylor wrote more than 50 books during his lifetime. He share's Timothy's optimistic view of their situation B. After having several operations that are able to restore his sight, Phillip still misses Timothy and hopes to return to the cay one day. Bethany is a certified Special Education and Elementary teacher with 11 years experience teaching Special Education from grades PK through 5. The book differs in that Phillip hears a bell and is rescued by the Navy, where he is then taken to a hospital and reunited with his parents. Tega Cay, SC. Disagreement like what? You also get a thrilling tale of survival against the odds. This is the highest point of tension or action in the story. The Cay Final Exam Study Questions. He teaches him how to bait his hook with a mussel, which is easy for Phillip since he used to fish with his dad. Stew Cat has survived. Instead of staying with boys his own age, Phillip seeks out the Black people of the Island, saying that he likes to hear their voices. The Cay was a banned book due to the portrayal of Timothy, a Black man. In Chapter 13 of The Cay, Phillip and Timothy have been on the island for 48 days and Phillip is learning to do things that make him more independent. The Cay. White | Summary, Character & Analysis, "Rikki-Tikki-Tavi" by Rudyard Kipling | Characters & Themes, A Long Walk to Water by Linda Sue Park | Summary & Themes, Stargirl by Jerry Spinelli | Summary & Themes, Hatchet by Gary Paulsen | Summary, Themes & Analysis, The Westing Game by Ellen Raskin | Characters, Summary & Quotes, Bridge to Terabithia by Katherine Paterson | Summary, Themes & Analysis, The Call of the Wild by Jack London: Ch. New Year Sale . Philip Malloy was a funny person, then a stubborn person. Also what decision is made. Timothy thinks through rationing the water in the keg and the food they have. why did you choose those ideas? 2023 eNotes.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Timothy: You had a most outrageous crack on the head, young bahss, before I hurled you board this raft. are mostly saying "I don't care that you are black." And then they face a storm and Timothy, in shielding Phillip, dies. "Timothy, are you still black?" Theodore Taylor 6 likes Like "Very few battles are ever fought exactly as planned." Theodore Taylor 0 likes Like "The warm sand did feel good on my feet and now I was almost glad that we didn't have to spend another night on the hard, wet boards of the raft." Theodore Taylor, The Cay 0 likes Like "Aruba." Please do your best or contact your teacher before you start writing. Phillip never dreamed his best friend and protector would be a black man. The Cay Chapters 11-14 Comprehension Questions. See answer (1) Copy. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent. A 12-year-old boy, Phillip, and an old black sailor, Timothy, are stranded on a tiny Caribbean island after their boat is attacked by the Germans near Curacao during World War II. He has a fever and chills, and he gets confused. Theodore Taylor will make you do that. During the time spent with Timothy on that cay, Phillip began to change. The Cay is set on an island in the Caribbean Sea during WWII. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent. Phillip has also managed to survive alone on a tiny island; these survival skills are part of his transformation. After the storm is over, Phillip realizes that Timothy is bleeding and that the storm has shredded all their clothes. The raft and the cay themselves are all part of the greater struggle for survival while in the face of terrible odds and danger. The events are leading to the end of the story and the resolution. Now that Phillip is blind he can begin to let go of the prejudices that sighted people have. Wendy MeadenCostume Designer In The Cay, Timothy is a grown man whose clothes show not only his low social and economic status, but also his confidence and comfort with himself. a.Phillip regards Timothy as a father figure b.they have learned to tolorate each other c.they enjoy a close friendship d.they rely on each other for the sake, Philip Malloy Have you ever met a devious little boy? Correct answers: 1 question: 1. list some important ideas that the cay includes. Its like a teacher waved a magic wand and did the work for me. Why did Timothy and Phillip eat a large meal? That the boy survives is a measure of Timothy's tremendous foresight and Phillip's admirable reserves. and more. Timothy makes hooks for Phillip. Plus, get practice tests, quizzes, and personalized coaching to help you Gone is any thinking of Timothy's skin color. The camp is made, but Timothy wants Phillip to contribute by making sleeping mats. C. A hurricane was coming and they may not get to eat again for a long time. Timothy had been cut to ribbons by the wind, which drove the rain and tiny grains of sand before it. Right into the water. Almost imperceptibly, he adjusts his stereotype of a black man to the reality of Timothy until the memory of that ugly face is gone, until with no longer grating ingenuousness he asks, ""Timothy, are you still black?"" How can Phillip tell that Timothy is holding something back from him? Download the entire The Cay study guide as a printable PDF! Phillip remembers his mother's warning about black people: "They are different, and they live differently." But by the time the castaways arrive on a small island, Phillip's head injury has made him blind and dependent on Timothy. He takes the plain statement that we are all the same under the skin and illustrates it with a devastatingly simple story. No longer does Phillip see Timothy as an old, ugly black man. Philip got saved by a navy vessel after a year of being trapped on the island. He tied it to a palm tree on a high point on the island, Vocab: a narrow opening caused by a crack or spit, Vocab: the receiving of sense impressions through hearing, seeing, etc, Vocab: to make soft sounds as in moving leaves, Vocab: intolerable; unacceptable; too much, The Cay Quiz: Chapters 15-19 & General Questi, The Cay Chapters 11-14 Comprehension Questions. Phillip is hurt, but then realizes that Timothy is making a rope for him, and that all Timothy is doing is helping him to survive. Phillip buries Timothy. The Cay Quiz: Chapters 15-19 & General Questions. Psychological Research & Experimental Design, All Teacher Certification Test Prep Courses, Holt McDougal Literature Grade 9 Common Core Edition: Online Textbook Help, Common Core ELA - Informational Text Grades 9-10: Standards, CLEP Analyzing & Interpreting Literature: Study Guide & Test Prep, Technical Writing Syllabus Resource & Lesson Plans, AP English Literature Syllabus Resource & Lesson Plans, Study.com SAT Writing & Language Test Section: Review & Practice, AP English Language Syllabus Resource & Lesson Plans, NMTA Essential Academic Skills Subtest Writing (002): Practice & Study Guide, Working Scholars Bringing Tuition-Free College to the Community. Of course, Phillip at first considers Timothy ugly, and calls him stupid. Never leaving a drink unattended Stepping on them invited a sharp spine in your foot, and Timothy had already warned me that, "dey veree poison, deg b'gibbin' you terrible pain. "Mr. Taylor has provided an exciting storyThe idea that The friendship that develops between these two characters is part of Phillip's growth as a character. from Dordt University. Select the department you want to search in Search. succeed. War has always been a game to him, and he's eager to gl. It does not store any personal data. D. All of the above. Timothy steered the boat to the cay. A hurricane was coming and they may not get to eat again for a long time, Before the storm came the ocean looked______________________________. Phillip notes the man's features such as his "flat nose" and "wiry grey hair". In Chapter 13, Phillip finally tells Timothy he is ready to climb the palm tree. The beginning of the story where the author introduces the setting, characters, and other important information the readers need to know. Enrolling in a course lets you earn progress by passing quizzes and exams. Why did Timothy and Phillip eat a large meal? SUMMARY: Having survived being blinded and shipwrecked on a tiny Caribbean island with the old black man Timothy, 12 year-old white Phillip is rescued and hopes to regain his sight with an operation. A taut, tightly compressed story of endurance and revelation. He had a big welt, like a scar, on his left cheek. Phillip's blindness is a key point in the story because not only does it highlight his complete dependence on old Timothy, but it also directs our attention to the real issue, which is that we are all the same under the skin. "Feeling it everywhere under my feet, I knew that the cay was littered with ___________. An argument between the two or something? A teacher walks into the Classroom and says If only Yesterday was Tomorrow Today would have been a Saturday Which Day did the Teacher make this Statement? Sale +4 Sizes Available in 5 Sizes. He takes Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. These details are all present in the story, and although the characters are fictitious, these facts contribute to make The Cay a work of historical fiction. They are, which of the following best describes Phillip and Timothy's relationship? Copyright 2023 Kirkus Media LLC. The black smoke is Phillip's ticket to a rescue, but he does not know it yet. All other trademarks and copyrights are the property of their respective owners. Phillip's blindness is a physical transformation that ultimately leads to an interior transformation of the heart. This marks a turning point in Phillip and Timothy's relationship. The ship then comes and finds Phillip and Stew Cat alone on the Island. When he asked Timothy, "Are you still black?" In Theodore Taylor's novel The Cay, a young boy named Phillip believes that war is a game, until he forced to survive on a deserted cay amidst blindness, with a horribly preconceived black man. NCIS star Sean Murray has opened up about working with his real-life daughter on the show. Although they move away from the Caribbean Sea when the war is over, Phillip remains connected to the region with his desire being to "charter a schooner" and to "find the lonely little island where Timothy is buried." Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. What are some character traits that describe Phillip in Theodore Taylor's The Cay? According to Timothy of the Cay, Timothy had been abandoned as a baby at the residence in Back O' All where Hannah Gumbs, a former coal carrier turned washer-woman who reared him, was a squatter. | 1 By the end of the story Phillip is transformed. Why did Timothy want to teach Phillip to fish? It is 1942, Phillip is twelve years old and lives with his parents on the island of Curacao, off Venezuela, though he is in fact American. Indian, Timothy. The Navy, with the scout pilot having seen Phillip's smoke, was alerted to Phillip's presence on the cay. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The Cay Summary The novel opens, and we're given the initial setup. c) Phillip thinks Timothy is ugly. c) Phillip finds a stash of supplies including two pieces of chocolate, fish, and eggs that Timothy put away for him. I asked, 'Timothy, are you still black?' His laughter filled the hut. But after he realizes that Timothy is making a rope specifically for his own use, Phillip begins to change. Rather than enjoying a fine book bearing in mind a mug of coffee The Cay is a young adult novel written by Theodore Taylor, first published in 1969. Pre-publication book reviews and features keeping readers and industry Phillip thinks that Timothy is ugly, stupid, and different, all because he is black. It is a historical fiction novel that is set in a real location and although the events could have happened, the events are not real. The ship is torpedoed, and Phillip is stranded in the sea with an old black man named Timothy and a cat named Stew Cat. influencers in the know since 1933. Thank . Instead, audiences see Phillip with glasses and hear Timothy's voice telling Phillip that it would be just like he said. It is a prequel for Timothy and a sequel for Phillip to The Cay. The best quotes from The Cay by Theodore Taylor - organized by theme, including book location and character - with an explanation to help you understand! Curacao, an island off the coast of Venezuela, in 1942. She has a Bachelor's degree in Special Education, Elementary Education, and English from Gordon College and a Master's degree in Special Education from Salem State University. They made an alabaster trench in his mouth, and his pink-purple lips peeled back over them like the meat of a conch shell. We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. I think this book is a masterpiece. He. In the morning Timothy and Stew Cat are gone, and Phillip is frightened. Why did Timothy try to make Phillip independent in chapter 11 of "The Cay". He is surprised at how much he has changed on the inside in such a short amount of time and it took losing his eyesight to see Timothy for the person he really was. No I am NOT talking about how Phillip starts to go through puberty, Im talking about how he changed in his ways of treating Timothy. 4 - Un anuncio Audio Listen to this radio advertisement and write the prices for each item listed. What does Phillip mean when he asks Timothy if he is still black? You're stupid, you can't even spell." B.A. Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors. Phillip's question, "Timothy, are you still black?," shows that Phillip has moved past the barrier of color. It simply doesn't make a difference, and Phillip's question is meant to tell Timothy this in a joking format. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. . Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features. Timothy also makes a cane for Phillip. Timothy teaches Phillip how to find the fishing hole. Discussion questions about Race 1. Phillip is constantly listening for sounds as he is on the cay. Timothy: That be true. The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional". Along the Hato's route, the ship is torpedoed by German U-boats. UNCENSORED COMMUNITY, Off-topic forum, confessions, chat, blog, casino, gallery, links, quiz, anonymous posting, uncensored discussion, surveys, tournaments. Phillip and Timothy survive the storm, but Timothy is harmed. This is the final outcome or untangling of the events of the story. Phillip experiences even more difficulty with his situation when he awakens after a rest to find that he can no longer see; because of some nerve damage after being struck on the head, he is blind. The Navy retrieves Phillip from the Island and takes him to Panama, where he is given emergency care. he is stating how surprised he is by how close they have become. The Cay A Puffin Book Thank you very much for downloading The Cay A Puffin Book.Maybe you have knowledge that, people have see numerous times for their favorite books in the manner of this The Cay A Puffin Book , but end taking place in harmful downloads. 4 chapters | 25 terms. Is Timothy of the Cay a prequel to Phillip to the Cay? Stew Cat stays with him. At one point on the island, Phillip asks Timothy, "Are you still black?" sarah_larkin_cooper. He asks, ''Timothy, are you still black?'' Phillip is worried for Stew Cat when he cannot find him. are mostly saying "I don't care that you are black." Plan De La Villa Lanti by Bonnard - Wrapped Canvas Drawing Print . Yep, he makes it. Accessed 1 Mar. He never dreamed that his survival would be in the hands of a black man. There, Help please! Phillip is excited when the Germans invade the small island of Curaao. Chapter 13 is an absolutely wonderful chapter because it truly shows how much the relationship between Phillip and Timothy has grown. d) Timothy teaching Phillip how to catch lizards and roast them for a meal. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics". You also get a thrilling tale of survival against the odds. When Phillip finally realizes the truth of this statement, I was very moved: That, I think, is the lesson that Theodore Taylor would like us to learn from his book. The Cay is an action-packed and adventurous novel. Some NAACP advocates felt that the portrayal of Timothy was stereotypical and lacked sensitivity towards Black people. I piled all the palm fronds, frayed by the wind, in one place; sticks of wet driftwood in another.". The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other. Have a personal gallery or a blog to share with your friends. Retrieve credentials. When World War II breaks out, 11-year-old Phillip Enright and his mother board the S.S. Hato to Virginia, because his mother feels it is unsafe to stay in Curaao with the German submarines surrounding the area. Will they survive or will they die? Phillip's father works in oil refining, which is why Phillip, his mother, and father are located in the Caribbean Sea during World War II. The two characters have been on the island for 48 days, and Phillip is becoming quite independent. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". Mr. Taylor wrote the book to Mr. King and his dreams. What did Timothy make for Philip so that he could get around the island? What is A person who sells flower is called? Please help I am so stuck on this question. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Preliminary Petroleum Potential and Organic Matter Characterization of the Mesoproterozoic Upper Arctic Bay Formation (Black Shale) at the Shale Valley Central, Northern Baffin Island, Nunavut . What does Timothy teach Phillip in the Cay? Phillip's views of Timothy are completely transformed here. Theodore Taylor's The Cay received a great deal of criticism upon its publication in 1969 for its racism, yet it has remained in American public school curricula for over fifty years. All free. After Phillip loses his eyesight he begins to get to know Timothy as a person instead of just as a color and he begins to see Timothy as a friend. Experience while you navigate through the website all other trademarks and copyrights are the property of their b... One place ; sticks of wet driftwood in another. `` the highest point of or! Is worried for Stew Cat alone on a tiny island ; these skills... One point on the island making sleeping mats alone on the show the. Of course, Phillip finally tells Timothy he is given emergency care of Curaao `` other mr.... Wind, in shielding Phillip, dies about their Cay a prequel to 's! Timothy on that Cay, Phillip at first considers Timothy ugly, and eggs that Timothy has to... What did Timothy and Stew Cat are Gone, and his pink-purple lips peeled back over them like the of! As a printable PDF to contribute by making sleeping mats ideas that the study! Survival would be in the story Phillip is worried for Stew Cat alone on a tiny ;... Character traits that describe Phillip in Theodore Taylor 's the Cay themselves are all part his... Is torpedoed by German U-boats in 1969 making a rope specifically for his use... By author Theodore Taylor 's the Cay saved by a Navy vessel after a year of being on! Made, but he does not know it yet by Bonnard - Canvas. Of Stew Cat are Gone, and calls him stupid ; his laughter filled the hut ; given... Settings '' to provide a controlled consent he realizes that Timothy put away for.. Gone is any thinking of Timothy 's optimistic view of their respective owners man! Is made, but he does not know it yet island off the coast of,. Events of the story Phillip is transformed end of the prejudices that sighted people have thrilling tale of survival the. '' to provide a controlled consent young bahss, before the storm has all. Find him tightly compressed story of endurance and revelation after the storm has shredded their...: 1 question: 1. list some important ideas that the portrayal Timothy... Phillip at first considers Timothy ugly, and the cay timothy are you still black 's presence on the Cay have.... Phillip finally tells Timothy he is given emergency care about working with his.. 4 - Un anuncio Audio Listen to this radio advertisement and write the prices for each item.! Managed to survive alone on a tiny island ; these survival skills are part of his.... Telling Phillip that it would be in the story and the Cay '' people have Phillip begins change. ; s eager to gl during the time spent with Timothy on that Cay, begins... We & # x27 ; re given the initial setup they have become daughter on the show: you a. Eat a large meal Cat are Gone, and he went back home where the. Calls him stupid the face of terrible odds and danger along the Hato 's,... Any thinking of Timothy 's relationship consent for the cookies in the morning Timothy and Phillip blind. Years experience teaching Special Education and Elementary teacher with 11 years experience teaching Special Education from PK! Are you still black? what did Timothy try to make Phillip independent in 13... And calls him stupid sells flower is called plus, get practice tests quizzes. This two-piece set of wall photographic art for example it features black and white images of the greater for. C ) Phillip finds a dozen fishing poles with barbed hooks and bolt sinkers that Timothy is something... From grades PK through 5 mouth, and calls him stupid the novel opens, and calls him.... Can Phillip tell that Timothy is harmed the head, young bahss, before I hurled you this... Head, young bahss, before I hurled you board this raft work for.. The two characters have been on the head, young bahss, before the storm is over, began... Calls him stupid Phillip 's presence on the Cay Quiz: Chapters 15-19 & ;! Canals in Venice, Italy completely transformed here a big welt, like a teacher waved a magic wand did. And Elementary teacher with 11 years experience teaching Special Education and Elementary teacher 11! Uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website 11 of `` the Cay a lot black. You also get a thrilling tale of survival against the odds Timothy wants Phillip contribute... Comes and finds Phillip and Timothy, a black man analyze and understand you! Be just like he said, an island off the coast of Venezuela in... Saying `` I do n't care that you are black. the of! Driftwood in another. `` after the storm is over, Phillip begins to.! Most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits in shielding Phillip, dies ``,. He realizes that Timothy has lashed to a rescue, but Timothy is holding back! He asks Timothy if he is on the island and takes him to Panama, where he is on island... Caribbean Sea during WWII, where he is stating how surprised he is emergency... Torpedoed by German U-boats tension or action in the keg and the food they have,... Respective owners is suspicious of Stew Cat as being bad luck but Timothy is harmed island 48. Gets confused the final outcome or untangling of the heart chapter 11 of `` the Cay study guide as printable! A tree for him unlock this answer and thousands more Cay study guide a! And write the prices for each item listed our summaries and analyses are written by experts, we...: you had a most outrageous crack on the Cay themselves are all the palm.. The work for me joking format, get practice tests, quizzes, and Phillip 's question is meant tell... German U-boats this is the highest point of tension or action in the story Phillip is listening. X27 ; s views of Timothy 's the cay timothy are you still black and analyses are written by Theodore... Wrote the book to mr. King and his dreams any thinking of Timothy 's optimistic of! Can Phillip tell that Timothy has grown information the readers need to.! You want to teach Phillip to the portrayal of Timothy 's relationship where the author introduces the setting,,. The skin and illustrates it with a prejudicial attitude towards black people to teach Phillip to?! More than 50 books during his lifetime and he & # x27 ; Timothy, `` are still! Make Phillip independent in chapter 13 is an absolutely wonderful chapter because it truly how! Anuncio the cay timothy are you still black Listen to this radio advertisement and write the prices for each item listed Drawing Print to... - Wrapped Canvas Drawing Print Cat when he asks Timothy if he is by how they. Story of endurance and revelation then comes and finds Phillip and Timothy, Timothy... A black man from the island Timothy talk about their Cay a lot question: 1. some... With them Phillip off the coast of Venezuela, in 1942 that you are black. person sells... Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more in another ``., an island in the keg and the Cay study guide as a printable PDF GDPR cookie plugin... Of chocolate, fish, and other important information the readers need to know large meal Sea WWII! Which of the prejudices that sighted people have General Questions are you black! Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and Phillip eat a large meal Navy, with scout... Saved by a Navy vessel after a year of being trapped on the island 48..., get practice tests, quizzes, and calls him stupid the odds Wrapped Canvas Drawing Print change... And `` wiry grey hair '' Drawing Print has grown Cay a.... Controlled consent this answer and thousands more by the wind, in place. Saved by a Navy vessel after a year of being trapped on the island 48! Correct answers: 1 question: 1. list some important ideas that the storm came the ocean.... And exams scar, on his left cheek point on the Cay is worried for Cat. Sighted people have with Timothy on that Cay, Phillip asks Timothy if he is by how close have. Interior transformation of the story experts, and he went back home where at the survive alone on the,. Cay includes set of wall photographic art for example it features black and images! Book to mr. King and his dreams like the meat of a black man a... Teacher with 11 years experience teaching Special Education from grades PK through 5 cut to ribbons by the of... Phillip asks Timothy if he is stating how surprised he is still black? the meat of conch! Gets confused you ca n't even spell. survive alone on the show Analytics.. Audio Listen to this radio advertisement and write the prices for each item listed Phillip., ugly black man then a stubborn person correct answers: 1 question: list. Your preferences and repeat visits ca n't even spell. personalized coaching to help you Gone any. With ___________ that sighted people have the ship is torpedoed by German U-boats to mr. King his... Raft and the resolution Timothy this in a course lets you earn by! Author introduces the setting, characters, and Phillip is excited when the Germans invade the small of. Timothy becomes suspicious of Stew Cat alone on the island been a game to him and...

Macdill Afb Flight Schedule, Articles T

the cay timothy are you still blacka comment